Review and Give-away: Energy-Wise Landscape Design
UPDATE: Ramble-On Rose wins the book – congratulations! The random number generator said “16” and her comment is the 16th. Thanks to everyone for playing, and for your great comments.
A furniture and harpsicord maker in rural Massachusetts takes up the study of landscape design, establishes a residential practice, then gets herself a publisher to spread the gospel of eco-friendly landscaping. Meet Sue Reed and her excellent book Energy-Wise Landscape Design.
Don’t be misled by the title – it’s not just about where to plant shade trees. It covers the whole eco-waterfront. Buying locally grown plants, avoiding peatmoss, conserving water, improving the
soil, filling our gardens with as many large, healthy plants as
About my pet issue Reed has lots to say and it’s a nice chunk of unusually helpful garden writing. After she stopped mowing 10 years ago, she still has to weed-wack to remove the 6-foot-tall Goldenrods and the woodies, and it’s “not a beautiful
wildflower meadow,” but it sure beats lawn. Love the honesty. Also, “Taking care of this
landscape might require a bit more attention than you’re used to giving
your lawn.” She suggests a “tidiness strip” to keep the neighbors happy, and recommends no-mow grass mixes.
About lawn removal, she raises a problem we’d rather ignore: “The process of eliminating
lawn grass can consume quite a lot of energy – either in the equipment
that mechanically removes lawn or in the herbicides that chemically
Her message isn’t anti-lawn but simply: Why have more than you need? And if you DO have lawn, read her “Five Problems
with Conventional Lawn Treatment” and her on-target guide to caring for it responsibly.
On Native Plants – a Nit-Pick
Reed is a graduate of the Conway School of Landscape Design, which she describes as “very idealistic”, and that idealism shows up in her discussion of native plants. “There’s no question that using native plants in our landscapes is a way to save energy.” How?” By providing essential services that save on energy (resources,
time, money). But her strict nativism bans even well adapted nonnatives that provide the same services (I’m looking at you, Sedums!) Also not okay are cultivars of native plants – species only. Her designs use only native plants and clients seek her out for that, so “It’s all to the good,” she told me on the phone. Also, “conventional garden beauty” is not her “main focus.”
That’s fine for the converted but what about the vast majority of potential readers? Why alienate them by declaring that nonnatives either do nothing for wildlife, or actually harm wildlife by becoming invasive? We need help choosing from among the thousands of (mostly nonnative) plants on offer – which ones are most self-sustaining, stormwater-retentive, and yes, useful for wildlife. But to recommend against clover, Hostas, daffodils, Sedums?? (Yes, I’m on a tear for Sedums – more about that coming soon.)
But with that small caveat about a small part of the book, I wholeheartedly recommend Reed’s book for covering the eco-landscape in such a readable and (mostly) practical way.
Leave a comment to win a copy before close of business Wednesday and I’ll choose one at random. Your comment can say anything at all – except please, none of those short and nonsensical spammy ones. (We’ve been inundated with spam comments lately, the somewhat smarter kind that responds slightly to the text or photos in the post. But we’re onto you – and we’re deleting your spammy URLs!)
I guess I had another mini-rant in me there – sorry about that!
on August 2, 2010 at 3:23 am, in the category Everybody’s a Critic, Gardening on the Planet.